Double, Double, Not Much Toil, Not Much Trouble:
Shakespeare in the Middle School Classroom

An invited article

Claudia Anne Katz
Highland Middle School


Note: After reading this article, please visit the transcript of the discussion forum to view readers' comments. And if you enjoy this article, you might also be interested in the review of Shakespeare for Kids, in the Professional Materials area of the Reviews section.






When Shakespeare wrote, "All the world's a stage," we felt he meant it. All the school's our stage, and we "strut and fret our hour upon it" mightily! Puck leaps out from behind a hidden stairwell. Star-crossed lovers die tragically in the upper addition hallway. Portia pleads Antonio's case across a row of desks stacked closely and precariously together. Tricksters giggle at Malvolio's foolishness behind a hedge of mops and buckets borrowed from Mrs. Spentos, our sympathetic patron and school custodian. Richard III dies a gruesome death at the end of a paper sword not too far from the new lunchroom. Perhaps he thought he could find a horse there? Many students insist it's possible.

Our community, located near a large urban center, attracts many talented actors who fuel frequent productions of plays by William Shakespeare. Early in the school year, I select a production that seems appealing. This affords me the opportunity to order tickets for the best seats in the house. I believe it is important for students to view a play intimately. The final celebration for our study of Shakespeare will be seeing a professional production.

Preparation takes about a month. I secure copies of the text. If a version of the play is in Albert Cullum's (1968) Shake Hands with Shakespeare, I start there. When there are no student versions, I use the original text and edit it directly on the copy. Most students prefer the original rendering.

I invite students to memorize selected passages. Romeo and Juliet yields many choices. Richard III had only one choice: "Now is the winter of our discontent, Made glorious summer by the sun of York..." (from Act I, scene i). Students have a week to commit the lines to memory. Every day students attempt to recite the lines before the class. This emphasis on spoken language produces an excellent listening audience.

I assist psychological set construction by briefly describing Shakespeare's Globe. I tell my students that most plays were done in daylight (Papp & Kirkland, 1988). I explain the three-level theater and the significance of placing characters at a particular level: angels and fairies appear at the top; ghosts emerge from beneath the stage. I stress the intimacy and popularity of the theater. The students are amazed to hear that Shakespeare's plays were not attended by English teachers in tuxedos, but by working folks from the street for whom the theater was not so different from our daily television soap operas. These "mechanicals" went often, frequently seeing a single play many times. The performance was intimate, with most of the audience standing at the apron of the stage. A soliloquy was not spoken by the actor as if he were alone, but to a group of "goundlings" who might discourse with him, answer his questions, and offer advice. For such a lively, interactive audience, the play had to be exciting. "Be prepared for plenty of innuendo and violence," I warn. All students respond positively on this account. They believe that Shakespeare provides them with authentic inclusion into the adult world.

Our lack of a proscenium stage is insignificant to students who stack up desks as a balcony, pose a male Juliet upon it, and track a very inconstant moon across a ceiling-sky with an overhead projector. "We have delayed long enough," I yell. "Push back the desks--let our rehearsals begin!" The front of the classroom becomes our stage. We keep chairs, stools, and tables ready in case we need them. Our props are cups, towels, a tablecloth or two, and red construction paper for bloody wounds. A rolled piece of chart paper will make a fine rapier. A pencil is an excellent dagger. Shakespeare used few sets and most of his props reside in his language.

I take a major part or two in the first scene. As Orlando in Twelfth Night, I recline on a table wrapped in a paper tablecloth and extol the soothing effects of music. I take all four parts in the opening of Julius Caesar and, after three performances, I realize I have memorized the entire first scene. I stuff a towel in the back of my sweater and become the hunchback Richard the Third. I am very silly! All my dignity is gone. I moan and groan and complain. I shout and scream and fall down and roll around. I let the students see that Shakespeare is wildly funny. There is no reverence in my voice, nor lofty tones or faux English accent. As I rock and roll through my part of the opening scene, I drag my audience in to participate. I force them to read lines to my character, to bellow as loudly as I, to be the fool and react to the fool. After the first scene is over, my student-actors are unafraid. I withdraw and become the director.

Our classroom staging is a collaboration where lines are carefully read to determine what Shakespeare might have wanted. Everyone gets a speaking role. Even the poorest reader can handle a small part. Players are encouraged to overact, to ham it up. I direct and redirect them until I am satisfied. We invite an audience -- usually some other class. They critique our efforts and we work some more. There is great method in our madness. Looking for character motivation, we discover that Macbeth's ambition fits perfectly in a season of presidential primaries. Incensed by the stubbornness of Juliet's father, Steve says, "If the parents had listened to those kids, they'd be alive today!" For these students the characters have become real.

    Angela returns from high school for a visit. Her first words, even before she says hello, are from Ariel's song:

    Full fathom five thy father lies,
    Of his bones are coral made;
    Those are pearls that were his eyes;
    Nothing of him hast fade,
    But doth suffer a sea-change
    Into something rich and strange.
    Sea nymphs hourly ring his knell:
    Hark! I hear them,--ding-dong bell.

    (Act I, scene ii, 396-403)

    "See, Mrs. Katz," she beams, "I still remember it!"

As our trip to the professional performance nears, anticipation grows. We discuss the behavior of an audience at a live production. They decide, without my suggestion, to "dress."

    We troop into the Goodman Theater with 175 seventh graders to see The Comedy of Errors. The adults present whisper, "They're too young. They'll never understand it." At the intermission, seventh graders are seen throughout the lobby explaining the action to the "older" audience. A woman approaches with a beaming student in tow, "I could never have understood this, without this boy!"

    I am standing in the aisle in the back of the Goodman Theater during a production of Romeo and Juliet. A man approaches. "Are you Mrs. Katz?" he says. I admit it, wondering what might have gone wrong. "I am Michael Maggio, the director of this play. I wanted to tell you that your students were the best audience we've had in a week of students' productions." This is high praise -- all the other audiences were high school and college students.

    We are attending a post-performance discussion of The Comedy of Errors. It has been a wonderfully silly production starring the juggling Brothers Karamazov. Students complain, "There wasn't enough Shakespeare in it."

In the classroom the day following the trip to the theater, spirits are high. Each act is eagerly discussed. Students often prefer our staging or characterization to that of the professional production. We photocopy newspaper reviews, analyze, agree and disagree with them. We are the actors, the directors, the producers, the audience, and the critics. Students will draw pictures of their favorite actor and, if the production is going on for a while, we send these to the theater to delight the cast. Students write thank-you notes to the theater and some even correspond with the actors and follow them when they appear in other productions around town. All the world has become our stage as we make Shakespeare a truly authentic experience in the middle school.

    Quiet now! I think I hear something. It is a carpenter and a cobbler in the hallway leading to the library. I think they are discussing Julius Caesar. I'd better take care of this. There might be ghosts under the choke cherry tree this year.

About the Author

Katz (e-mail, CKatz17755@aol.com) has been a middle school teacher for 36 years. She currently teaches grade 8 at Highland Middle School, Libertyville, Illinois, USA, and is undertaking a doctoral program in reading at National Louis University. She is chair of IRA's Middle School Reading Special Interest Group and is the immediate past president of the Illinois Reading Council and a former columnist for the Journal of Adolescent and Adult Literacy.

Back to article


References

Adams, P.E. (1985). Teaching Romeo and Juliet in the nontracked English classroom. Journal of Reading, 38, 424-432.

Cullum, A. (1968). Shake hands with Shakespeare. New York: Citation.

Crafton, L. (1991). Whole Language: Getting started...moving forward. Katonah, NY: Richard C Owen.

Lamb, C., & Lamb, M. (1957). Tales from Shakespeare. London: Dent & Sons.

Papp, J., & Kirkland, E. (1988). Shakespeare alive! New York: Bantam.

Shakespeare, W. (1980). Works. New York: Signet.

Go to the discussion forum.





Reading Online, www.readingonline.org
Posted March 1999
© 1999-2000 International Reading Association, Inc.   ISSN 1096-1232